REVIEW: ‘Winter’s Bone’

Grade: B+

In my review of 2009’s Oscar nominated film Precious I stated that it was incredibly difficult to objectively review the film because the realism that is presented is so detached from my own circumstances. After seeing Debra Granik’s gritty Winter’s Bone I find myself faced with a similar conundrum, although not to such an extreme.

For people living in the rural areas of the Ozark mountains a fulfilled life is not one of luxury. The goal for an individual is simply to survive rather than thrive in the harsh natural and social environment. The world presented in Debra Granik’s dark thriller seems desolate and cold, but through the female protagonist it manages to glimmer with hope. Brilliantly filmed against the poetic landscapes of the Ozark mountains, Winter’s Bone is a glimpse into rural morality and the emergence of an unlikely hero.

Relative newcomer Jennifer Lawrence is a shoe-in for an Oscar nomination for her performance as Ree Dolly, a 17-year old with a lot of responsibility. She is the chief caregiver of her two younger siblings, she lives with her nearly catatonic mother, and she only occasionally shows up for school. Her meth-dealing father has been arrested, posted the family’s house as bail, and vanished. If he does not show up at court, the family will lose their house and be thrown into a world where they have more enemies than friends.

The narrative is essentially straight forward, which allows Granik to lace the film with tension. Granik brilliantly proves that action does not equal tension and most scenes start and end on high notes with an anticipated release that never comes. At its heart, Winter’s Bone is a film noir with a missing person chase, a look into an underground crime world, and a feeling of constant danger. Lawrence successfully creates a new feminist hero that also harkens back to the great noir detectives of the 1940s.

In a low populated area like the rural Ozarks, the morality that is presented does not fit the mold that urban and suburban dwellers have become accustomed to. When a significant portion of the workforce consists of unskilled laborers, the job market is incredibly volatile. In one scene Ree sees her only two possible futures in two separate school rooms – join the army and escape or become a mother and join her miserable relatives.

Nobody appears content with their existence in Winter’s Bone except for the children who only appear in the film in brief segments where they can be seen jumping on a trampoline or playing in hay. The fact that the children get such joy out of such meager circumstances shows that Ree’s fight is worth it.

Bottom Line: Winter’s Bone is subtle, thrilling and an inspiring tale of what makes life worth fighting for.

, ,

  • I want to see this film so much, but I think I may have to wait until DVD. So few theaters are showing it, and of course we have to devote thousands of screens to “SATC2” and “Jonah Hex”. Not that I’m bitter or anything.

    Glad you enjoyed.

  • Jose

    G, the film could have an expansion since its per theater average is stonger than SATC2 and Jonah Hex combined, when I looked at it at boxofficce mojo it had the 4th highest average in the top 30.
    Alex, I just finished the book, any idea as to how close the movie is to it?

    I too am anticipating this movie.

  • I have not read the book, but considering it is a film of mostly silence I’m not sure how close it is.

  • Todd

    I’ll predict this will be like the hurt locker and win best picture and best actress. At this point im not realy sure theyd give a woman best director for the 2nd year in a row.

  • Quin

    I really want to see this. G1000, you have such a point. Movies like “The Lasy Airbender”, “Sex and the City 2″, Jonah Hex”, “The A-Team” are playing on thousands of screens. Meanwhile, good films, like “The Kids Are Alright” and “Winter’s Bone” and playing so few screens. Its Outrageous.

  • I just saw it and i think it will be snubbed in the Best Picture category. Lawrence deserves Actress nomination. She was very good and she had her Oscar moment.

  • I must express thanks to you just for bailing me out of this circumstance. Because of researching throughout the world-wide-web and seeing methods which are not helpful, I was thinking my life was well over. Living without the strategies to the issues you have sorted out as a result of your main blog post is a serious case, and the kind that would have badly affected my entire career if I hadn’t discovered your web page. Your actual expertise and kindness in touching every item was excellent. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not discovered such a stuff like this. I’m able to at this time look ahead to my future. Thanks very much for your professional and results-oriented help. I will not hesitate to propose your web blog to anybody who would like counselling about this subject matter.

Privacy Polcy | Contact Us